Scientific Article Evaluation System

The evaluation process of scientific articles is conducted through a double anonymous peer review, meaning that both the reviewer’s and the author’s identities remain undisclosed throughout the process.

Evaluation Criteria

  • Relevance and Novelty of the Topic – 25 points

  • Evidence-Based Justification of Research – reliability, consistency, and logical reasoning of arguments; particular attention is given to the extent to which the cited scientific literature corresponds to the research question (20 points)

  • Validity and Reliability – assessment of the accuracy and credibility of the references and literature used in the article (15 points)

  • Technical Aspects of the Article – compliance with citation rules, writing style, and structural consistency (15 points)

  • Research Findings – extent to which the research addresses the specific field and responds to the challenges of modern science (25 points)

Scoring and Publication

  • The maximum possible score is 100 points.

  • Articles are eligible for publication only if they receive a positive evaluation, defined as a score of 51 points or higher.

Submission Guidelines

Authors must submit the electronic version of their article to the following e-mail address:

📧 a.tsiklauri@alterbridge.edu.ge